
Trump, Xi Jinping, and Putin are going to meet in Shenzhen at the APEC summit. That’s the first time the leaders of the three biggest nuclear powers will sit down together, so I put up some thoughts at 1945 magazine on what might come out of it. The White House says the agenda is nukes and Iran, not Ukraine, and no one is expecting a deal.
The best realistic outcome would be some movement toward a three-way strategic arms control deal. New START expired in February, after Trump turned down Putin’s offer to informally keep its limits for another year. So for the first time in decades there’s nothing capping US and Russian arsenals, and China is building up fast. A three-way arms race is a lot harder to stabilize than the old two-way Cold War one, because each side has to hedge against two rivals at once. If Trump could pull off a trilateral deal, it would be a genuine legacy win for him, which is not something I say often.
But I doubt it will happen, for three reasons:
- Putin sees Russia’s nuclear arsenal as its last real claim to great-power status. He’s not going to give that up cheaply, and Moscow wants British and French warheads counted too.
- Xi won’t accept permanent nuclear inferiority to the US. Beijing says joining arms control talks now would be unfair and unrealistic.
- Trump doesn’t have the patience for this. Arms control is slow, technical, and detail-heavy, which is about the worst possible fit for Trump’s style.
Ukraine is even less likely. Trump can’t deliver Ukrainian concessions; the Abu Dhabi talks are deadlocked, and Putin is reportedly demanding even more territory beyond the Donbas. Xi and Trump both have leverage over Putin, but neither seems willing to use it. And as I argued back in July, Putin has no route to actually winning the war, so he’s just dragging it out.
So expect a handshake photo and some vague language about ‘strategic stability.’ A three-way nuclear deal is a long shot; peace in Ukraine is an even longer one. Read the rest here.
You must be logged in to post a comment.